The Galápagos Affair

Introduction

In the early 1930s, a small, uninhabited island in the Galápagos archipelago became the stage for a bizarre and tragic human drama. Floreana Island attracted three distinct groups of European settlers, each seeking a utopia detached from civilization. Instead of paradise, their coexistence descended into jealousy, disappearing bodies, and suspicion that remains unresolved nearly a century later.

Historical Context

The first to arrive were Dr. Friedrich Ritter and Dore Strauch, a German couple devoted to Nietzschean philosophy and raw living. They were followed by the Wittmer family, seeking a quiet life for their sickly son. The precarious balance was shattered by the arrival of the "Baroness" Eloise von Wagner-Bosquet and her two lovers, who announced plans to build a luxury hotel for millionaires. The Baroness's flamboyant and domineering behavior quickly alienated the other settlers.

The Disappearances

The tension culminated in March 1934. The Baroness and one of her lovers, Robert Philippson, vanished without a trace. The remaining lover, Rudolf Lorenz, claimed they had departed for Tahiti on a passing yacht, yet no ship had been seen, and they left behind nearly all their possessions. Shortly after, Lorenz himself hurriedly attempted to leave the island with a Norwegian fisherman. Their bodies were later found desiccated on Marchena Island, having apparently died of thirst.

Evidence & Findings

Dr. Ritter died later that same year, reportedly from food poisoning after eating spoiled chicken, though Dore Strauch claimed he cursed the Wittmers with his dying breath. The Wittmers remained on the island and became its historians, but their accounts often contradicted Strauch's. No physical evidence of the Baroness or Philippson was ever found—no bodies, no shallow graves.

Theories

The prevailing theory is that the Baroness and Philippson were murdered by Rudolf Lorenz, possibly with the aid or complicity of the Wittmers and Dr. Ritter, who all despised her. Lorenz's subsequent flee and death is viewed as a flight from guilt. Margaret Wittmer, who lived on the island until 2000, steadfastly maintained the "Tahiti" story, famously telling reporters, "She is gone. That is all."

Unanswered Questions

Did the Wittmers help Lorenz dispose of the bodies? Was Dr. Ritter's death truly accidental, or did Dore Strauch hasten his end after years of abuse? The complete lack of forensic evidence means the truth lies buried in the volcanic soil of Floreana, guarded by the silence of its last survivors.

Sources

• The Galapagos Affair: Satan Came to Eden (Documentary).
• Postcards from Floreana by Margaret Wittmer.
• Satan Came to Eden by Dore Strauch.

Disclaimer